Wednesday, 12 November 2008

War reporting essay

I've been away a while... Work has been manic the past month but I thought I'd update the blog with some advice for those Journalism students taking MAC373: Media Ethics and Contexts, who plan on attempting the following question:
2. Habermas (2004) claimed ‘the critical state of a democracy can be measured by taking the pulse of the life of its political public sphere’. He also claimed ‘the public sphere serves those who have gained prominence as a stage for self-presentation’. How does the public’s right to participate in political life measure up against the journalist’s responsibility to serve the democratic process when considering sensitive stories?

A good answer is likely to consider the role and responsibilities of journalists in informing the democratic process. It may be advantageous to consider these issues against the backdrop of examples whereby the media appear complicit in preventing the public from accessing accurate information in a timely manner, for instance the news that Prince Harry was serving in Helmand, Afghanistan
Most of the material I have covered on the module to date has been informed by the core concern of democratic action within public life as informed by the media. Obviously, the work of Habermas on the 'public sphere' is important to this essay in that it serves as the theoretical basis for starting the investigation. Those students on MAC373 attempting this question will need to engage with Habermas' ideas in some form in order to complete the assignment.

I've posted copies of the slides used in the session on war reporting as a way of showing one way into the assignment:
Mac373 Reporting War 2008
View SlideShare presentation or Upload your own. (tags: war mac373)


You can find all of my presentations in the relevant folders in the MAC373 module space on WebCT Vista/Sunspace. I thought it might be useful for some of you to recap the ideas raised on MAC201 last year so I've included those slides here too:
News And The Public Sphere
View SlideShare presentation or Upload your own. (tags: mac201 news)

Tackling the essay

Some of the things that you are going to need to do in order to answer this question:
  1. Explain what is meant by 'democracy'
  2. Define the 'public sphere'
  3. Relate the 'public sphere' to the press/broadcasting (the role of 'public opinion'?)
  4. Consider some of the failings of the public sphere (is the press free from commercial concerns? do the public interact freely with news? do some voices/perspectives dominate the news agenda?)
  5. By this point in the essay, it should be possible to make some over-arching claims about the role the press plays in lubricating the cogs of democratic action
  6. The next stage of the essay should revolve around an example of your choosing - the only caveat is that the story or case study should be 'sensitive' in some way (ie politically or militarily dangerous, perhaps even concerned with privacy issues)
  7. You will need to engage with whether or not the public has a right to know or if the journalist/publisher/broadcaster has a right to withhold the information
  8. Is press freedom sacrosant?
The example you decide to touch on is up to you, but you might want to check with me first to ensure that it is substantial enough to suit the purpose. I have suggested that you might want to consider the example of the media blackout surrounding Prince Harry's 10 week tour of duty in Afghanistan, which leaked via the Internet. This is not the only example that you can use but it is an accessible one.

The story was thought to be subject to a DA-Notice in the British context as the mission was militarily sensitive, until the US-based Drudge Report picked up on an earlier Australian story and broke the news. At this point the British media opened up - there are lots of interesting newspaper accounts of whether the public had the right to know the whereabouts of the Prince, or whether or not it was prudent to not reveal his location for fear that it may endanger his fellow troops (see the links in the first slideshow above)

Was the Prince a likely target for the Taliban? Or was the stunt a PR exercise in order to raise troop morale? Did the media blackout even matter given the reports that the Taliban already knew Harry was there? Who really benefitted from the blackout? Prof. Roy Greenslade makes a few interesting observations in his Guardian blog piece here that you might want to check out.

You could also approach the question from a historical perspective. A famous example of when the British media dealt with a controversial story which might have been militarily sensitive can be seen in the This Week documentary entitled Death on the Rock. In 1988 the programme investigated an incident in which 3 members of the IRA were shot in Gibraltar by British special forces. Conflictual evidence led to public uncertainty about the legitimacy of the shootings. Did the public have the right to know?

You can watch the broadcast below:


Another famous example of a gag-order being served came in the Spycatcher case, when a former MI5 published sensitive information. The Times was carrying a story recently about a forthcoming book entitled Secrecy and the Media: The Official History of the D-Notice History by Rear-Admiral Nicholas John Wilkinson which was itself subject to D-Notice wranglings, and has been subsequently delayed by the publishers (Routledge). A couple of weeks back The Independent carried a story about palns to extend the powers of the DA Notice system, referring to a specific example

If you want to talk specifics then leave a comment or send me a plan or outline via email.

4 comments:

david james said...

I do not want to permit eccentric somebody additional’s process as my possess so I would love to mend on the rate of the process I arm in. I acquire been lesson up on the qualities of a Essay State on your blog so I belief it boosts.

Xj Cheng said...

For added ascendancy over a time adjustment,a Microstella bend can be acclimated to replica watches acclimatize the antithesis caster on the central of the watch.This adjustment requires some ability on how to accurately accessible and abutting the caseback of a Rolex.Both methods are discussed below.A Rolex watch is a attribute of abundance to abounding people.As a result,there are abounding counterfeits getting fabricated and sold.Abounding humans are blind about the uses of the replica accoutrements afar from its accessible artful use.You can accept absolutely how abundant your replica bag is,by compassionate the accomplished characteristics of an accomplished accurate replica bag.A superior replica bag looks and feels like an accurate handbag.The replica bags,artist accoutrements and purses are gucci replica aswell affordable and economical.Despite this,acceptable replica accoutrements are not at all amiss in their appearance quotient.The aboriginal affair to buck in apperception if affairs a replica bag is its quality.There can be abounding stores,which try to advance in your duke bad superior replica accoutrements and absolve the auction on the base of the low amount of the bag.Don't you accept them!This is because accomplished superior defines chanel replica a acceptable replica bag and replica handbag.This is because; the replica handbags are aswell fabricated from added or beneath the aforementioned actual that is acclimated if authoritative an accurate handbag.So try and get your replica backpack from stores,which replica watches uk don't compromise,on the superior alone because of the low amount of such bags.

John said...

cheap air max
michael kors bags
cartier watches for sale
polo ralph lauren
hollister co
coach factory outlet online
versace
pandora charms
coach purses
cheap oakleys outlet
air force 1
designer handbags
oakey sunglasses wholesale
levis 501
coach outlet online
reebok uk
burberry outlet online
running shoes
puma shoes
ray ban sunglasses
nike air max
fitflops shoes
hollister sale
true religion outlet
ray ban sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
cheap jordans
nike trainers
cheap nfl jerseys
louboutin outlet
toms outlet
coach factory outlet
designer handbags outlet
jordans shoes
abercrombie and fitch
fitflops sale
lululemon sale
polo ralph lauren
2016513yuanyuan

hoxn Ln said...

a couple months between Replica watches UK charges.Even though Breitling Replica debuted the Emergency II in 2013, Replica handbags it was not until now in the summer of 2015 that the watch is finally available for sale in Replica watches the United States. Why did it take so long? More so, the Emergency II is still not certified for sales in handbag replica some other important countries such as Russia, Canada, and Germany (it should be noted that even if Rolex Daytona the Emergency II watch .

Post a Comment