Monday, 30 January 2012

War or gaming fun? Spotting the difference

A week ago I wrote a piece about ITV's blunder in which video game footage taken from YouTube found it's way into a documentary about Gaddafi. Ofcom were less than pleased with the lack of due process and compliance breaches on display. A few days ago, a BBC picture editor (Phil Coomes) wrote a playful piece in which he stressed the blurring of real and virtual worlds given the popularity and success of increasingly photorealistic video games depicting war or conflicts.

I only came across this article after a colleague of mine forwarded me the URL devoid of context. I think he knew it would wind me up and the gist of my response to the article can be found below.


I get pretty confused about these kinds of posts from journalists, in which they attempt to link the digital representations of (usually) fictional war-based games with real world combat. I get that still images can look similar but there's a world of difference between experiencing war first hand and picking up a controller or a mouse and playing in a virtual world with strangers on the Internet (as in Battlefield 3 or Modern Warfare 3). Granted, Coomes was responding to a point raised by the photographer John Cantile, who claimed that the level of realism was such that the "next sufferers of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) may not even have left their bedrooms". The rest of the article seems to give way to Cantile's experiences rather than being the work of Coomes.

What irks me about these kinds of claims is the easy at which the impacts of one experience (war) are neatly overlaid  onto that of another (gaming) at the level of photorealism. You'd think that there's never been a thing called cinema in which actors depict realistic events a la vérite. When reading through the Ofcom report into the ITV blunder it's almost understandable how the game footage form ArmA 2 made it's way into a documentary - a failure of basic fact-checking before running with something grabbed from the internet, but it's another thing entirely to compare gaming to the real experience of warfare. This should be apparent to Cantile as he has photographed battalions in Sirte, Libya.


I'm sure Cantile felt "drained" after playing Battlefield 3 for many hours - I do too, but I also feel really drained after playing FIFA or Fat Princess online for large periods of time. However, I don't make the mistake of thinking that I am at the Bernabéu of that I've ever really played there, setting up goals for Lionel Messi and basking in the cheers or boos from fans and oppositional supporters alike.

The sound mix for Battlefield 3 is phenomenal - you can get incredibly disoriented with rockets and explosions erupting all around your character. This really can be a "hellish cacophony"as Cantile claims. It sounds even better with an expensive pair of headphones but that can break the verisimilitude - it's not often soldiers storm battlefields with big headphones, a games controller or a mouse and keyboard. I note he was a playing on PC - the only real injury the contemporary digital soldier will experience is Repetitive Strain Injury?

I know what happens when a player gets gets shot in Battlefield 3 as I've been killed several thousand times. You get a kill-cam of the player who shot you, overlaid with stats about your 'nemesis' (eg their weapon, their class, their personal kill/death ratio) before being dumped to a character load-out screen to do it all again. Very real. And let's not even go into how bad the texture 'pop-in' is on the PS3, further heightening the supposed reality effect! The texture mapping and frame-rate hardly contributes to the replication of reality (neither does having an on screen radar or ammo count). Just witness the realistic text effects below:


Cantile has spent some time attempting to match real world images to those taken in-game saying: "In some cases it is actually quite hard to tell the difference between my photographs and the computer version, which is deeply worrying. The level of detail is so precise that the virtual war zone is as convincing as the real thing". I'm not sure how worrying it is. As I've alluded to earlier, there are many other media forms that "look" real, but are not - they are representational or, in the case of games, simulational (see Gonzalo Frasca on this point). I think this is the underlying anxiety in the article - a point that is hinted at rather than explicitly addressed, and one which has connections with other moral panics about media forms and their supposed effects.

So the essence of the piece can be summarised thusly: still images taken from some war-based video games look like real combat environments. And rightly so given that vast swathes of research money has been vested in making these products look similar to the actions they depict in order to ramp up the dramatic experiences of gameplay. But it's somewhat disingenuous to claim that we should be worried about the similarities between static images of two completely different experiences 


Julia David said...

I really appreciate this blog and I will sure promote this blog to others in my circle.
access BitSnoop in UK

maymay said...

Stylist Attire Ideas: Knitwear are usually just about the most chanel outlet items of garments. It is possible to outfit these upwards or perhaps straight down. To get a everyday seem, use the cardigan together with a couple of extensive lower leg denims and several bangle necklaces. These kinds of garments ideas are usually chosen regarding expecting mothers who would like to develop a weight reduction seem, keep stylish and a lot gucci replica, sense gorgeous. If you are sporting one thing you never sense excellent inside, it's going to present. There isn't any reasons why you can not appearance and feel beautiful although carrying a child. Buckskin could be the many popular things nowadays inside almost everything. Whether it be outfit, shoes or boots, belt, louis vuitton replica, hand protection, accessories and so forth in every buckskin are usually very desired. That is probably the leading selections for folks nowadays. And also you will want to, all things considered it really is this kind of stylish cloth which it justifies this kind of recognize. Buckskin is indeed significantly popular plus it seems extremely stylish and also sophisticated also but nevertheless it's got a single drawback which is the nasty scent. Specially when buckskin will be fresh that scents quite high. This is a huge lunchmoney away from for folks. Whether it be almost any buckskin my partner and i. elizabeth. normal buckskin or perhaps fake buckskin or perhaps man made buckskin this kind of negative scent will be frequent between almost all. And also buckskin scents a whole lot worse when grow to be damp. And also in case you are fantastic admirer regarding hermes replica outfit this kind of drawback can cause several issues to suit your needs since no-one would want to appear towards you.

Robert F. Crocker said...

I really appreciate this blog

Deborah Richards said...

You can also fill out some of the "no purchase to enter" sweepstakes for a much smaller amount of stars. Kim kardashian hack

Keron Rowskey said...

Such a nice blog post. Interested people can look forward for the best Online Casino Australia.

Awais Ahmed said...

In the next few years, we will see which technology becomes the winner. In the meantime, it's best to make due with the 3D systems we've got. But 3D doesn't need to be restricted to just movies, because it can also be used in games. Ofcourse, games have been 3D for quite some time already. The one downside of 3D games is that they appear on a 2D monitor screen.

John said...

ghd hair straighteners
michael kors outlet online
nike air max
adidas nmd white
reebok shoes
gucci borse
rolex replica watches
kate spade outlet
nike cortez
coach outlet online
ralph lauren uk
basketball shoes
chi flat iron
coach outlet
cheap ray-ban sunglasses
kate spade outlet
true religion jeans
michael kors outlet
jimmy choo shoes
oakley sunglasses outlet
under armour outlet
michael kors outlet
gucci outlet
yeezy boost 350
supra for sale
ralph lauren outlet
rolex watches
chaussure louboutin
yeezy boost 350
michael kors handbgas
sac longchamp
vans shoes
louis vuitton borse
oakley sunglasses
mlb jerseys wholesale
adidas trainers
ray ban sunglasses
louboutin pas cher

林东 said...

nike free flyknit
nike free flyknit 4.0
birkenstock sandals
louis vuitton factory outlet
michael kors handbags
birkenstock sandals
timberland boots
timberland outlet
pandora outlet
ray ban sunglasses
ray ban sunglasses discount
pandora charms
nike air force 1
nike air force white
coach factory outlet
coach outlet
oakley sunglasses
timberland boots
ralph lauren outlet
nike free flyknit
nike free flyknit 4.0
mont blanc pens
ray ban sunglasses discount
abercrombie and fitch
kobe shoes
kobe 9
nike free run
nike free run black
ralph lauren outlet

Muneer Ahmed said...

Along these lines, the primary thing that you have to consider is the prerequisite and utilization of the mouse then select the mouse as per you're gaming needs. Source

seo boss said...

In established truth a few people work it on their every day processing work, they setup profiles to work for specific application, suppose Photoshop, Word, PowerPoint, and so on.

hoxn Ln said...

we are still new to Replica Watches understanding how to compare various carbon polymer materials with one another. Moreover, we still need to handbag replica gain a lot of expertise and information to know whose cases are Replica handbags better than others, why, and if materials such as “Breitlight” are indeed a proprietary blend, or Replica watches UK a slick name a brand like Breitling applies to this type of material.There are a lot of open questions about carbon composite Rolex Daytona .

Mikaela Yngvildr said...

It’s difficult to find well-informed people about this subject, however, you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks Source.

Bert Carl said...

Adidas Messi 16 FG
Nike Air Max Motion LW
Air Jordan 4
Adidas Ultra Boost Olympic
Supra Bleeker Women
Timberland 6 Inch Boots
Nike Zoom Ascention Men
MBT Kitabu Gtx Shoes
Air Jordan 2 Men
Adidas D Rose 7 Men

ninest123 said...

mont blanc pens
christian louboutin outlet
pandora jewelry
coach outlet
cheap jordans free shipping
kate spade handbags
nike free run black
birkenstock pas cher

Post a Comment